Best for Comprehensive Hair Care: Hers, Amazon | Jump to Review
Best for Convenient Accessibility: Rogaine, Amazon | Jump to Review
Best for Natural Ingredients: Nutrafol, Amazon | Jump to Review
Hers, Rogaine, and Nutrafol are all brands that offer hair loss treatments that may effectively treat hair shedding and thinning. However, each brand provides different benefits and drawbacks. While Hers and Rogaine both offer topical minoxidil, Hers also offers a variety of other treatments, including oral minoxidil, hair vitamins, and topical minoxidil with finasteride. Nutrafol offers drug-free nutraceutical supplements for hair loss due to stress, hormones, and nutrient deficiencies, making it a great option for those looking for a more natural approach.
Hair loss can be caused by genetic factors, stress, hormonal imbalances, nutrient deficiencies, aging, and more. When looking for a hair loss treatment, it’s important to consider the underlying cause of it. We always recommend reaching out to your healthcare provider or dermatologist prior to beginning treatment to ensure that it is safe for you to use.
In this article, we’ll compare Hers, Rogaine, and Nutrafol to help you find the best hair loss treatment for your needs. We also spoke with Dr. Jonathan Rick, a board-certified dermatologist, about his thoughts on each brand, their effectiveness, and who each provider may work best for.
Hers offers a wide variety of treatments, namely minoxidil in a range of forms and strengths. This platform also offers compounded treatments with multiple active ingredients and customized dosages. It may work best for individuals who want to address hair loss with multiple medications and will benefit from ongoing virtual care.
Rogaine offers the most extensive clinical backing with FDA-approved topical minoxidil for female pattern hair loss. It’s widely available online and from in-person drugstores, making it the easiest to obtain. However, Rogaine may not work best for hair loss from non-genetic factors, like stress and nutrient deficiencies.
Nutrafol is an excellent option for individuals seeking a drug-free treatment for thinning hair due to nutrient deficiencies, stress, and hormonal fluctuations. However, it’s expensive and its ingredients aren’t as extensively researched as minoxidil.
Hers vs. Rogaine vs. Nutrafol | Hers | Rogaine | Nutrafol |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hair loss products | Minoxidil + Hair Vitamins Minoxidil + Biotin Oral Minoxidil Minoxidil 2% Minoxidil 5% Finasteride + Minoxidil spray Hair masks, shampoos, conditioners | Minoxidil Solution Minoxidil Foam | Drug-free nutraceutical supplements Hair masks, shampoos, conditioners |
| Price | $18 to $44/month | Starting at $32.99 | $88 for 1-month supply of nutraceutical |
| Minoxidil strength | Up to 7% | 2 and 5% | ❌ |
| Prescription required? | 🟡 Most products | ❌ | ❌ |
| Application method(s) | Solution Foam Tablets Chewables | Solution Foam | Capsules |
| Multiple active ingredients in one formula? | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ |
| Blocks DHT? | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ |
| Clinically tested? | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ |
| FDA-approved ingredients? | ✅ | ✅ | ❌ |
| Where can it be purchased? | Brand's website Amazon | Brand's website Amazon In-person pharmacies | Brand's website Amazon |
| Website |
Hers vs. Rogaine
Hers and Rogaine both offer topical minoxidil in 2% and 5% formulations (the only FDA-approved treatment for female pattern hair loss). However, Hers also offers a range of other treatments, including over-the-counter options and compounded medications, along with ongoing physician support. But, Rogaine has earned more extensive clinical backing and is widely available at in-person drugstores. Overall, Hers is a more well-rounded option for treating androgenic alopecia.
Hers vs. Nutrafol
Hers offers medicated and over-the-counter treatments for hair loss, while Nutrafol only offers nutraceutical supplements. Some of Hers’ hair loss treatments can block DHT, making it the superior option for female pattern baldness. However, for hair thinning from nutrient deficiencies, stress, and lifestyle factors, Nutrafol is an effective, natural alternative.
Nutrafol vs. Rogaine
Nutrafol offers oral nutraceutical supplements for thinning hair, while Rogaine is a topical treatment for female pattern baldness. Rogaine is FDA-approved, unlike Nutrafol, but can’t address hair loss due to non-genetic factors, like poor nutrition and stress. Additionally, Nutrafol is significantly more expensive than Rogaine at $88 for a one-month supply.
1. Hers Hair Loss Review
Overview
- Price range: $18 to $44 per month
- Helps with: Androgenic alopecia and hair loss due to nutrient deficiencies, menopause, aging, and hormones
- Time it takes to work: 3 to 6 months
- Availability: Hers website, Amazon
Hers is a popular telemedicine platform that addresses many common health concerns, including hair loss. Its range of prescription and over-the-counter treatments targets hair loss from androgenic alopecia, nutrient deficiencies, menopause, aging, and hormonal imbalances. The platform uses research-backed ingredients in customized dosages to promote hair regrowth within 3 to 6 months.
Non-prescription hair loss treatments can be bought from Hers with a one-time purchase or subscription. To get a hair loss prescription, you’ll need to complete an online questionnaire about your medical history and hair concerns. One of the platform’s licensed physicians will review your answers and provide a prescription (if appropriate) to be shipped to your door.
A Word From Our Expert
— Dr. Jonathan Rick
Services such as Hers offer minoxidil, but can also prescribe other products aimed to slow hair loss. For individuals wanting to approach hair loss from several directions, Hers allows quick access to prescription medication and full treatment plans. However, it should be noted that not all hair loss is androgenic and there are several important conditions that can cause hair loss and require attention from a medical professional to diagnose.”
Related reading: Hers Hair Loss Review – Can It Regrow Thinning Hair?
Hers Pros & Cons
Pros
- Offers both prescription and over-the-counter treatment options
- Provides free ongoing physician support for questions and dosage adjustments
- Offers compounded formulas with clinically proven ingredients to address multiple types of hair loss
Cons
- Side effects may be more common with prescription-strength treatments
- Not as extensively researched as Rogaine
Hers Products for Hair Regrowth
Hers offers a wide variety of oral and topical treatments to promote hair regrowth:
- Hair Vitamins + Minoxidil is a prescription tablet containing minoxidil, biotin, and vitamins C, B5, and B6. Minoxidil boosts circulation to the hair follicles and prolongs the hair growth phase. Biotin can help prevent shedding, and vitamins C, B5, and B6 can support overall hair health.
- Biotin + Minoxidil Chew is a lemon-flavored, once-daily prescription medication with minoxidil and biotin. Minoxidil encourages new hair growth over time while biotin curbs shedding.
- Oral Minoxidil is a once-daily prescription pill that supports hair regrowth. It’s often considered for individuals who experience side effects, like scalp irritation, from topical minoxidil.
- Minoxidil 5% Foam is Hers’ generic version of Rogaine. It’s FDA-approved to promote hair regrowth within 3 to 6 months. Minoxidil foam may work well for those who want to avoid the systemic side effects that can accompany oral minoxidil.
- Minoxidil 2% Topical Solution absorbs directly into the scalp to activate the hair follicles and extend the hair growth cycle. It’s the generic form of Rogaine’s 2% minoxidil solution.
- Hair Blends Solution is a topical, prescription treatment that combines minoxidil, biotin, ketoconazole, and vitamin B5. Ketoconazole is an antifungal drug that can help prolong the hair growth phase in people with androgenic alopecia. Vitamin B5 may stimulate cell development to support hair regrowth.
- Hair Blends Postmeno Serum and Postmenopausal Hair Loss Spray are topical treatments containing finasteride and minoxidil. They’re specifically formulated for individuals in the postmenopausal stage of life and work by preventing future hair loss and boosting new hair growth.
- Biotin Builder Gummies are a daily multivitamin with biotin, vitamin B12, vitamin B6, vitamin D, and folic acid. This may be a good option for individuals seeking a non-prescription treatment and those experiencing hair loss due to nutrient deficiencies.
- Triple Threat Shampoo and Conditioner are non-medicated, color-safe hair products with saw palmetto and pumpkin seed oil to prevent shedding. The blends also contain amino acids and argan, coconut, and sunflower seed oils to boost hair hydration.
Hers Hair Loss Treatments Side Effects
Hers hair loss treatments containing minoxidil and/or finasteride can trigger side effects. Prescription-strength formulations are the most likely to cause side effects.
Side effects of oral minoxidil may include:
- Excessive hair growth
- Increased heart rate
- Swelling in the feet
- Dizziness or lightheadedness
- Headaches
- Mild blood pressure changes
Side effects of topical minoxidil may include:
- Scalp irritation, itching, dryness, scaling, flaking, or burning
- Unwanted facial hair growth
- Changes in hair color or texture
Side effects of topical finasteride may include:
- Scalp itchiness, irritation, or burning
- Redness
- Contact dermatitis
Seek emergency medical care if you experience:
- New or worsening chest pain
- Chest pain that spreads to the jaw or shoulder
- Rapid or pounding heartbeats
- Rapid weight gain (mainly in the face and midsection)
- Severe skin reaction
- Lightheadedness
- Shortness of breath
- Fluid in the lungs
2. Rogaine Women’s Hair Loss Review
Overview
- Price range: Starts at $32.99 per bottle
- Helps with: Androgenic alopecia
- Time it takes to work: 2 to 4 months
- Availability: Amazon, Rogaine website, in-person drugstores
Rogaine is a longstanding brand of topical minoxidil foam for hair loss. Unlike other brands, it’s widely available from in-person drugstores and online retailers, making it one of the most accessible hair loss treatments. So, you can either place an order online or pick up a bottle at your local pharmacy. Additionally, Rogaine has been FDA-approved to treat androgenic alopecia since 1988, so it’s often recommended by dermatologists.
A Word From Our Expert
— Dr. Jonathan Rick
Topical minoxidil is a cost-effective treatment for several types of hair loss. There is a wealth of data and experience showing that this is an effective product, especially for androgenic alopecia, or male or female pattern hair loss."
Related reading: Does Rogaine Work on Eyebrows?
Rogaine Pros & Cons
Pros
- FDA-approved since 1988 for androgenic alopecia
- Backed by extensive clinical research
- Widely recommended by dermatologists
- Conveniently available from in-person drugstores and online
Cons
- Doesn’t address all types/causes of hair loss
- May cause scalp irritation
Rogaine Products for Hair Regrowth
Rogaine offers the following treatments for hair regrowth:
- Women’s 5% Minoxidil Unscented Foam is Rogaine’s strongest formulation. 5% topical minoxidil has provided superior results for hair loss in some studies, although it’s more likely to cause side effects, like scalp irritation.
- Women’s 2% Minoxidil Solution is a topical treatment administered through a dropper. Some people prefer a solution to foam, as it can be less messy. Additionally, while the 2% solution is less potent, it’s also less likely to cause side effects than the 5% foam.
Hers Minoxidil and Rogaine are similar treatments for androgenic alopecia. Each is available in a 5% foam or 2% solution. However, Hers offers the option to combine topical minoxidil with other active ingredients, including ketoconazole and finasteride. Additionally, with Hers, you can reach out to one of the platform’s physicians with questions or concerns at any point. With Rogaine, you’ll need to schedule an appointment with a physician separately.
Rogaine Side Effects
Side effects of Rogaine may include:
- Scalp irritation, itching, dryness, scaling, flaking, or burning
- Unwanted facial hair growth
- Changes in hair color or texture
The Rogaine 5% is more likely to trigger side effects than the 2% solution, as it’s a stronger formulation.
Contact your doctor immediately if you experience any of the following symptoms:
- Severe scalp irritation
- Chest pain
- Rapid heartbeat
- Rapid weight gain
- Swelling in the hands or feet
- Confusion
- Flushing
3. Nutrafol Women’s Hair Loss Review
Overview
- Price range: $88 per month
- Helps with: Hair loss related to nutrient deficiencies, stress, and more
- Time it takes to work: 3 to 6 months
- Availability: Nutrafol website, Amazon
Nutrafol is a leading brand of nutraceuticals formulated to treat thinning hair from nutrient deficiencies and stress. The natural-drug-free supplements contain the patented Synergen Complex® with ashwagandha, saw palmetto, tocotrienols, marine collagen peptides, and curcumin for hair health. Nutrafol also offers supplements designed for vegans, individuals over age 45, and people in the postpartum stage.
Supplements from Nutrafol are non-medicated, so you can purchase them online without a prescription.
A Word From Our Expert
— Dr. Jonathan Rick
Nutrafol does actually have some good data behind it. I think it works but it is quite pricey, and more affordable options should probably be used first.”
Nutrafol Pros & Cons
Pros
- Patented Synergen Complex® contains research-backed nutraceuticals for hair growth
- Addresses multiple causes of hair loss, including stress, aging, and metabolism
- Vegan and postpartum options are available
- Side effects are uncommon
Cons
- More expensive than other options at $88 per month
- 4 capsules daily is the serving size, which isn’t ideal for those who don’t like swallowing pills
Nutrafol Products for Hair Regrowth
Nutrafol supplements are formulated with a blend of nutraceuticals to support hair growth by lowering stress levels, supporting metabolic function, optimizing nutrient levels, and curbing the effects of aging on hair.
- Nutrafol Women is a daily hair growth nutraceutical for individuals ages 18 to 44 with hair thinning. It’s intended to address common causes of thinning including nutrition, stress, metabolism, and lifestyle factors. Ingredients in this blend include biotin, saw palmetto, and hydrolyzed marine collagen, among others.
- Women’s Vegan is a vegan alternative for Nutrafol Women. It contains 100% vegan ingredients including Sensoril ashwagandha, moldavian dragonhead, tocotrienol complex, curcumin, and saw palmetto, which address thinning by reducing cortisol levels and promoting new hair growth.
- Women’s Balance is formulated for individuals over age 45 with hair thinning. It specifically targets thinning triggered by menopause-related factors, including hormones, stress, metabolism, nutrition, lifestyle factors, and aging. Women’s Balance contains Nutrafol’s Synergen Complex® Plus, which includes a few additional ingredients, like maca root powder.
- Nutrafol Postpartum supplement was developed by OB/GYNs to support hair growth in the first year after giving birth or breastfeeding. It’s breastfeeding-friendly and promotes overall recovery with marine collagen, theanine, shatavari, and DHA omega-3s.
You can use Nutrafol and Rogaine together because Nutrafol is a dietary supplement, while Rogaine is a topical medication. They work differently to support hair regrowth. However, it’s always best to check with your healthcare provider before trying them together.
Nutrafol Hair Loss Treatment Side Effects
Nutrafol is a dietary supplement, rather than a prescription medication, so side effects are fairly rare. However, some of the ingredients in Nutrafol can cause side effects:
- Collagen can trigger indigestion, headache, diarrhea, and a bad taste in the mouth.
- Saw palmetto can cause headaches and digestive symptoms.
- Ashwagandha can cause nausea, upset stomach, diarrhea, and vomiting.
These side effects generally occur in high doses. Taking the recommended daily dose of Nutrafol prevents adverse reactions.
Seek emergency medical care if you experience symptoms of a severe allergic reaction, including:
- Swelling of the tongue, lips, or throat
- Difficulty breathing
- Rash, hives, or extreme itching
- Dizziness
- Fainting
- Shortness of breath
The Verdict: Which Is the Best Women’s Hair Loss Treatment?
Overall, Hers, Rogaine, and Nutrafol are all legitimate hair loss treatment options.
Hers is the best option for a comprehensive care regimen.
Hers is the best option for a comprehensive care regimen, as it offers a broad selection of prescription and over-the-counter hair loss treatments. Hers uses clinically-researched ingredients and offers a generic version of Rogine. However, Hers doesn’t have the same degree of clinical backing as Rogaine.
Rogaine is the most convenient.
Rogaine is the most convenient, accessible option for female pattern hair loss, as it’s available both online and at drugstores. It’s FDA-approved to treat androgenic alopecia, but isn’t the best option for other forms of hair loss.
Nutrafol is the best option for individuals seeking a natural solution.
Nutrafol is the best option for individuals seeking a natural solution for hair thinning due to nutrient deficiencies or stress. While Nutrafol can address many of the root causes of hair loss, it’s the most expensive treatment in this comparison.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What happens when you stop using Hers?
When you stop using Hers, the normal hair loss process will start back up, and new hair growth will gradually go away within a few months.
Does Nutrafol have minoxidil in it?
No, Nutrafol doesn’t have minoxidil in it.
What is more effective than minoxidil?
Minoxidil is considered one of the most effective treatments for androgenic alopecia. Other options include spironolactone, dutasteride, finasteride, and nutritional supplements.
Is there anything better than Rogaine?
Some people experience better results with Hers or Nutrafol than Rogaine.
Do dermatologists recommend Nutrafol?
Yes, Nutrafol is widely recommended by dermatologists.
Methodology
To find the best hair loss providers, we started by searching for any that were specifically designed for hair loss for those assigned female at birth. Next, we narrowed our list down to only the highest-rated and most popular, effective, convenient, and affordable options. We then evaluated the service based on its features, ease of use, reputation, customer service, quality of care, and reviews. We also considered the service’s effectiveness, affordability, and safety. Finally, we tested Hers, Rogaine, and Nutrafol to see how safe, simple, and effective they were for hair loss.
We ultimately made our decision based on the treatments’ results, accessibility, cost-effectiveness, and risk of side effects.
| Review Process | Key Metrics | Weighting |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase online | – ease to complete intake form – affordability – upfront commitment or subscription required? – money back guarantee or refund policy? | 1 |
| Shipping + unboxing | – shipping cost – time from order to treatment delivery – sustainable packaging | 1 |
| Testing + journal for 1-3 months | – ease of use – transition into habitual use – taste / smell / feel / pain | 1.5 |
| Results after 3 months of use | – efficacy / results – ease of forming a health habit – requires additional purchae? – responsive customer support – willingness to recommend to a friend | 1.5 |
Related Reading
Topical Finasteride and Minoxidil Spray Review – What’s the Best 2-in-1 Topical for Hair Loss?
If you’ve been looking into treatment for pattern hair loss (androgenic alopecia), you may have come across the ingredients minoxidil and finasteride, which are the two most popular and clinically-backed treatments for thinning hair that come in both oral and topical form. Brands like Hims,
Tretinoin and Hair Loss: Does It Help Regrow Hair?
Key Takeaways Topical tretinoin may support hair growth by increasing circulation to the scalp and boosting cell turnover. Up-to-date clinical research indicates that tretinoin can enhance the effects of minoxidil for hair growth. The most common side effects of tretinoin are skin irritation, dryness, and
Red Light Therapy for Hair Loss: Does It Promote ReGrowth?
Key Takeaways Red light therapy can safely and effectively treat hair loss in some individuals. It typically takes four to six months to see results from red light therapy. Red light therapy can promote regrowth and hair retention. While many types of red light therapy
How to Get Oral Minoxidil Online: A Complete Guide
Key Takeaways Oral minoxidil is a good option for individuals with androgenic alopecia who experience side effects from topical minoxidil or who are not seeing the results they hoped for. You can get an oral minoxidil prescription online by completing a virtual consultation with a
Does High Blood Pressure Cause Hair Loss?
Key Takeaways While some studies do show a potential association between high blood pressure and hair loss, more research is still needed. High blood pressure can affect blood flow, potentially impacting blood flow to the scalp and hair follicles. Some medications used to treat high
Dense Hair Experts Review: What Do They Offer for Men’s Hair Loss?
Dense Hair Experts Overview Price: £59.99 (or £47.99 on subscription) Prescription products: Finasteride, dutasteride OTC products: Minoxidil, shampoo, conditioner, vitamins, styling products Active ingredients: Finasteride, dutasteride, minoxidil Potential side effects: Itching, redness, flaking Who it’s best for: Individuals experiencing male pattern baldness Go to Site→
