Ironically, finding a matchmaking service can be almost as hard as finding a partner. That’s saying a lot, because while there seems to be an endless array of options to swipe through, meeting someone you can build a life with is no easy feat.
Tinder, Bumble, Hinge, OKCupid, and Coffee Meets Bagel offer many successful testimonials, but if you’ve grown tired of cycling through the same unfulfilling options with little to show for it, then it may be time to try a more surgical approach.
Online matchmakers, believe it or not, are thriving in the post-Tinder era, especially among affluent professionals who don’t have enough time for casual dating.
Tawkify and Three Day Rule are the two most popular modern matchmaking services currently, connecting thousands each year with partners with similar lifestyles, values, and goals. Today we’ll compare these two industry leaders to help you decide which might be the right fit for you. We’ll also explore key factors to consider when choosing a matchmaking service in general, as well as our personal experience, so you can stop wasting time on apps and start making more meaningful connections.
Tawkify vs TDR | |
– White-glove experience: Tawkify only approves applicants they believe they can match. This ensures clients receive high-touch service. They even eliminate the pressure of crafting the perfect date, planning everything for you. – Background checks: Tawkify verifies the identity of all its users and performs criminal background checks for safety. – Coaching: Tawkify’s coaches help you overcome anxiety, so you can maintain a fun, open mind. – Guaranteed matches: Tawkify guarantees a certain number of matches so you won’t be left hanging without prospects. This makes the ROI feel more tangible as well. – Affordable: Tawkify offers a $99 option that gives you exposure to potential matches.
Cons– Wait list: Tawkify is highly selective about the clients they work with, which means you may not be able to join right away if they are at capacity. | 
– Hand-selected matches: The matchmakers at Three Day Rule personally screen and select every match on their platform based on preference and compatibility. – Insights from each match: Your matchmaker provides feedback to help make future dates more worthwhile. – No blind dates: Three Day Rule provides their clients with information about a match prior to their date, including photos and a brief bio.
Cons– Limited locations: Three Day Rule matchmaking services are only available in select US cities, so this can immediately rule it out for some people. – Expensive: Three Day Rule is for the elite. The high price point can make it feel like a huge gamble, especially since you have to commit to an expensive package upfront. It’s inaccessible to all except the few disposable budget for dating. |
Three Day Rule vs Tawkify: How do they compare?
Three Day Rule vs Tawkify | ||
|---|---|---|
| Membership price |
|
|
| Database size | 🟡 | 1 million+ |
| Gender ratio | 🟡 | 🟡 |
| Free database? | ✅ | ✅ |
| Relationship types (hetero/LGBT)? | ✅ | ✅ |
| Success rate | 🟡 | 80% |
| Background checks? | ✅ | ✅ |
| Guaranteed matching? | ❌ | ✅ |
| Date planning? | ❌ | ✅ |
| Date coaching? | ✅ | ✅ |
| Avg. User Rating | 4.5/5 (Yelp) 2.9/5 (Trust Pilot) | 4.5/5 (Trust Pilot) |
| Geographical coverage |
| All 50 states |
| Website |
Is a personalized matchmaker worth it?
It’s natural to feel skeptical about paying a stranger on the internet to set you up romantically. Could it really be better than using your own intuition? You never know what you’re in for, but for many, that’s what makes it so exciting and potentially wonderful.
Even though no service can guarantee a soulmate, they can at least offer you the opportunity to meet like-minded people with whom you share common interests and values from the get-go.
Serious-relationship seekers are also more likely to hire a matchmaking service than twiddling their thumbs on a dating app. This means that if you’ve had no luck finding a committed partner on Tinder and co., you may have better luck meeting someone who is serious about finding love through a matchmaker.
As for whether an online, personalized matchmaking service is worth it for you, the answer comes down to a few key factors:
Access to a Personal Matchmaker: One of the greatest benefits of a matchmaking service is access to a personal dating expert who can help you find what you’re looking for in a partner. Both Three Day Rule and Tawkify use personal matchmakers to provide you with more tailored matches rooted in deeper compatibility vs. the superficial attraction on dating apps.
↑ Compatibility Probability = Time Savings: Along with personalized matchmaking comes a higher chance of meeting someone you want to keep seeing. The matchmaker considers your lifestyle, values, future plans, goals, and beliefs to help find you someone. Whatever kind of long-term partner you’re looking for is sure to compliment what they are looking for as well, offering a higher chance of successful partnership.
One of the most frustrating parts of dating online is sorting through all of the profiles you aren’t interested in. Someone can easily spend hours a week just trying to find matches to talk to, let alone organize dates with. A personal matchmaker takes all the stress and hassle out of the process, so you just need to receive matches, go on dates, and see where it takes you.
Because the matchmaker does all the work of screening potential suitors, you can focus on getting to know the hand-picked options they introduce you to.
Feedback and Coaching: Personalized matchmaking also comes with feedback to help you become a more confident dating partner. It also includes feedback on why matches didn’t work out, so you can adjust your approach if necessary and improve your chances of finding a great partner in the future.
How do online matchmaking services work?
You know the stress of trying to write the perfect dating app bio? You know, a profile that’s equal parts funny, authentic, and charming? Working with a personal matchmaker is a lot easier than that. The process is relatively straightforward and only requires a few steps:
- Create Your Initial Profile: You will fill out a questionnaire about your preferences, lifestyle, values, and what you’re looking for in both a partner and future relationship. This information will go onto your profile in a database, which your future matchmaker will use to help find potential matches. The matchmakers of other clients can also see your profile, and they’ll reach out to your matchmaker to arrange a date if they think there could be a connection.
- Choose Your Ideal Approach: Users are offered different membership packages that increase their number of matches and access to additional features, like dating coaching. You can go all-out from the start or ease into the matchmaking game by paying for the cheapest tier. We suggest taking it slow, meeting a match first, and seeing what you want to do from there. Paying thousands of extra dollars upfront does not mean you’re more likely to meet your dream partner sooner. It’s best to go slow, check out the service, and upgrade if you feel like they’re worth your money.
- Meet Your Matchmaker: Clients are paired with a dedicated matchmaker who serves as their connection between all future matches. You can think of your matchmaker as a mutual friend that arranges your dates. The matchmaker will review your profile, then get to know you better by asking questions about your relationship goals and history. They are there to help you find someone you can see a future with.
- Pre-arranged dates: Your matchmaker will plan a date based on you and your match’s personalities and interests. From there, you get to show up and see who they’ve paired you with. This can be an anxiety-inducing experience for many, but if you keep an open mind and remember there’s zero pressure, you can have a good time. Because dates are planned for you, you can worry less about impressing your potential match with the right ambiance and focus solely on getting to know them.
Tawkify Review: Best for finding a committed relationship
Tawkify is America’s leading matchmaking service. Over the last 10 years, they’ve paired up 150k+ couples, and they are committed to adding a personal touch to our cold and disconnected modern dating world.
There are several features that make Tawkify so popular among elite singles:
In-depth Personal Consultations
The Tawkify team gets to know you and understand what you’re looking for. They learn about your preferences, values, and relationship history to help assess possible chemistry and compatibility with future dates.
Hand-selected matches
Their epic database and proactive search strategies help you find matches worth meeting. Every match selection hinges on a background check and live video interviews to assess personality, appearance, and compatibility beyond a static profile.
Curated Date Experiences
Tawkify handles all the details of planning a date, so you can arrive relaxed and ready to explore a new connection. They also communicate all post-date feedback and follow-ups, all while keeping your full identity and contact info private until you’re ready to share.
Focused Collaboration
Every new match you receive is influenced by feedback from your last date, which helps refine the matchmaker’s search strategy. Each date debrief is complimented by supportive coaching that helps you gain new insights about your dating style. This ultimately leads to more clarity and confidence that make you an even greater catch.
How does Tawkify match clients?
Tawkify has the country’s largest network of over 1 million singles called the Romance Rolodex, and new candidates are added every day. They have the knowledge and numbers to help you find your person.
The personalized matchmaking service prides itself on a curated approach. Unlike some services that accept anyone willing to pay, Tawkify only selects clients who meet their high standards.
To become a client, applicants must take an in-depth screening call with a Tawkify matchmaker. During the call, the matchmaker asks about their dating history, preferences, and relationship goals to figure out whether they’re a fit for the platform.
By limiting their active client base at any given time, the matchmakers guarantee they can get to know date-seekers on a deeper level and theoretically help them find more compatible matches.
Tawkify’s hyper-exclusivity by design sets it apart from alternative matchmaking services. They work closely with clients who are serious about finding someone special and softly reject the rest, making sure matches have all been thoroughly screened and vetted.
What is Tawkify’s success rate?
Tawkify claims they have an 80% success rate at helping people find a partner. Although that number hasn’t been validated by an independent third party, there are lots of other signals that hint at Tawkify’s efficacy. For instance, their high Trustpilot score of 4.5/5 indicates that thousands of customers have found a loving partner on the platform.
Tawkify Reviews - What do customers say online?
Three Day Rule Review
Three Day Rule’s premium matchmaking service connects singles with potential partners through a personalized compatibility assessment. Their team consists of professional matchmakers, dating coaches, and even stylists who help clients look and feel their best, build confidence, and forge deeper connections with their dates.
A few key features of Three Day Rule include:
Hand-selected Matches
All of the matches at Three Day Rule are hand-selected by highly trained matchmakers who scout out potential dates in the real world. They’ll approach people in classes, on Instagram, and even off the street. That last one may put you off, but don’t worry, the matches are all vetted before they’re added to the database.
Data Feedback Advantage
If you’ve ever gone on a date and wondered, “What went wrong?,” you can finally get the answer. Your matchmaker offers personal feedback after you meet a match to talk about what worked, what didn’t, and how you can improve your connections in the future.
No Blind Dates
Once matches are pre-screened and approved by a matchmaker, clients get to review photos and a profile to decide whether they would like to take the next step forward to meet in person.
How does Three Day Rule work?
Three Day Rule allows people to sign up for their free database and have their profile listed after completing the screening process. The company is particularly known for its proactive approach to matchmaking. They don’t wait for the best matches to come to them—they get out in the world and find them.
In addition to recruiting people on social media, they’ll also attend classes and events to recruit eligible singles in real life. Whether it’s at a yoga class or on Instagram, the matchmakers at Three Day Rule are always working hard to find matches for their clients.
In some instances, Three Day Rule matchmakers have even approached people on the street who they felt might be a good fit for one of their clients. The dedication they have for their clients is admirable, and it leads to more personalized matches that can lead to meaningful relationships.
What is Three Day Rule’s success rate?
On Yelp, the company’s claimed profile has an average rating of 4.5/5. Trustpilot tells a different story, though. With only two reviews at the time of publishing, Three Day Rule’s aggregate rating was only 2.9/5.
Credible statistics that declare likelihood of finding a partner through a matchmaker vs a dating app are hard to come by, but intuitively, personalized matches (from friends, family, or a professional service) seem much more likely to lead to better dates than randomly swiping through profiles. It’s a quality over quantity approach, and for busy people, it’s generally much more effective than blindly playing the volume game.
Three Day Rule Customer Reviews
The Verdict: Is Tawkify or TDR worth it?
Both Tawkify and Three Day Rule are both well-established, professional matchmaking services in the US. TDR’s services is a bit more geographically limited (i.e. only available in certain cities), while Tawkify is available nationwide.
Both services have successfully matched many life-long partners, but aren’t without negative reviews online, meaning clients’ experience seems to be somewhat mixed. This should be unsurprising, however, as even skilled matchmakers can’t possibly guarantee two people, regardless of how compatible they seem, will hit it off in person 100% of the time.
That said, matchmaking could be the right choice if you’re tired of wasting time on dating apps, seeking something serious, and want to accelerate your search with the help of a professional to save time. Ultimately, the services are likely too expense to try at the same time, so if we have to choose just one…
Tawkify is our #1 pick. | |
Tawkify is our favorite online matchmaking service. It’s ideal for individuals who value privacy (your personal info is never revealed to others prior to meeting in person) and who are looking for exclusively high-quality (read: affluent) candidates.
Daters’ experience with the service is much more passive than TDR’s — Tawkify handles everything, including date planning and has much higher customer reviews online.
Plus it’s a lot more affordable as well. For just $99 / month you can join the platform and unlock the potential to get matched, and for $500/ month you can access you own personalized matchmaker / dating coach. While that’s not cheap, there’s no commitment, unlike Three Day Rule which locks you in to a multi-month plan.
| |
Three Day Rule is expensive, but legit. | |
Three Day Rule is best if you want help accelerating your search without sacrificing control. Their service allows you to see profile pictures prior to meeting, plan your own dates, and generally stay in the driver’s seat with professional guidance and coaching.
With highly trained experts scouting and screening your matches, TDR offers a personalized and meaningful matchmaking experience that can be worth it for busy folks who don’t mind committing a few thousand bucks for a few months of hyper-targeted matches.
| |
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
What are some things to consider when using a matchmaking service?
There are many factors to look into when reviewing matchmaking services. For starters, your own dating goals and desires are ideal. Then, you should think about how much flexibility you want in a platform, whether or not you want dating coaching, and if you’re open to blind dates and being more open-minded with matches.
What sets online matchmaking services apart from other online dating options?
Matchmaking services take the stress out of finding matches. They replace the typical dating app algorithms and use human matchmakers to gauge compatibility. You save time attending mixers, events, and other meet-ups in hopes of finding someone in real life, and get to meet matches already pre-screened for you instead.
How long does it take to find a compatible match through a matchmaking service?
While you can get a match guaranteed with packages from various services, there is no straightforward answer as to how long it takes to meet someone you have a strong connection with. In general, most people seem to meet someone they continue to see after a few matches.
What kind of background checks do matchmaking services conduct on potential matches?
Matchmaking services each screen candidates differently. We suggest looking for ones that perform criminal background checks, live video interviews, and identity verification to protect their clients.
How do matchmaking services maintain privacy and confidentiality?
Databases are private, and only first names are revealed to potential matches. No contact information is exchanged between dates unless they wish to do so.
Do matchmaking services guarantee matches or offer refunds?
There are some matchmaking services that guarantee a specific number of matches in a set period of time, but none of them promise you’ll find a person to start a long-term relationship with. For this reason, refunds are rare as the client enters the contract understanding that matches may be guaranteed, but true compatibility and mutual attraction are not.
How does Three Day Rule charge?
Three Day Rule charges membership fees based on the number of months of service:
- 3 months: $5,900 (~$2k / month)
- 6 months: $9,500 ($1,583 / month)
- VIP: $18,500
You can create a free profile and browse profiles, but you won’t be able to message anyone or initiate a date. This pricing model is in contrast to Tawkify, which offers a personalized match service starting at $500 per month without any commitment.
How does Tawkify charge?
You can join Tawkify’s database for just $99 / month if you want to open yourself up to potential matches without any proactive control.
For ~$500 to $1,000 per month, you can get your own personal matchmaker and at least one guaranteed date per month. There are more expensive packages as well depending on your goals and urgency to find your soulmate.
Methodology
We conduct extensive research to evaluate the pricing, effectiveness, accessibility, overall quality, and user experience of each product we review. This also included examining and comparing them to several alternatives.
| Review Process | Key Metrics | Weighting |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase online | – ease to complete intake form – affordability – upfront commitment or subscription required? – money back guarantee or refund policy? | 1 |
| Shipping + unboxing | – shipping cost – time from order to treatment delivery – sustainable packaging | 1 |
| Testing + journal for 1-3 months | – ease of use – transition into habitual use – taste / smell / feel / pain | 1.5 |
| Results after 3 months of use | – efficacy / results – ease of forming a health habit – requires additional purchae? – responsive customer support – willingness to recommend to a friend | 1.5 |
More Wellness Reading
Average Health Coach Salary: Insights for Those Wondering If This Career Is Worth It
With an average yearly salary of $55,672 in the U.S., health coaching is a worthwhile career for those interested in the health and wellness space who want to focus on supporting others. Health coaches in Delaware, Alaska, and Washington DC, as well as in major
What to Expect From a Life Coach and How to Get the Most Out of Your Coaching Experience
Life coaching has emerged as a strategy for overcoming personal and professional challenges. Distinct from therapists and counselors, life coaches focus on helping their clients identify their strengths and meet future goals. While life coaches don’t have to undergo regulated training, like therapists, various life
Topics to Be Coached On: Discovering What People Want From Coaching
People seek out the services of coaches for a multitude of reasons. Individuals may seek out coaches to assist them in working towards specific or broader goals, whether they pertain to career advancement, personal development, health and well-being, or other life domains. Depending on an
Coach vs. Therapist: What’s the Difference, and Which Is Right for You?
Key Takeaways: Therapists have advanced degrees and formal licensing; coaches may have varied backgrounds and certifications. Therapy focuses on mental health, while coaching focuses on personal development and goal achievement. A therapist is able to diagnose mental health conditions, while a coach can not make
PlushCare Anxiety Review: Is It Best for Online Therapy & Anxiety Meds?
Telehealth platforms, like PlushCare, allow you to prioritize your mental health in a more convenient and affordable way. With PlushCare’s online platform, you won’t have to rearrange your schedule, worry about transportation, or leave home to connect with a therapist or doctor, even if
Klarity Anxiety Review – Pros, Cons, Alternatives, & More
Affecting over 40 million American adults each year, anxiety is one of the most common mental health conditions. Regardless of the type of anxiety condition, they are all highly treatable, with many individuals experiencing symptom reduction or relief with appropriate treatment. Finding treatment, booking
